By Monique
Another day, another whitewashing controversy. This one has been brewing for some days now, and it involves a historical film called Ni’ihau.
The film is based on a true story of a Japanese WWII pilot crash landing on Hawaii, where he was taken in by local leader Ben Kanahele. Here’s the full scoop from Deadline:
…Shigenori Nishikaichi, an Imperial Japanese Navy Air Service pilott, crash-landed his Zero on the eponymous Hawaiian island after participating in the attack on Pearl Harbor. [Zach] McGowan will play Ben Kanahele, an island leader who saves Nishikaichi before learning his part in the attack. When the circumstances became apparent, Nishikaichi was apprehended but received assistance from locals, taking hostages and attempting to overcome his captors. Kanahele ultimately killed Nishikaichi and was decorated for his part in stopping the takeover.
The Ni’ihau Incident led to President Franklin D. Roosevelt issuing Executive Order 9066, which led directly to the mass internment of 119,803 Japanese-American men, women and children until the end of the war.
27 Ten Productions’ Ken Petrie said that with this film being a true story, “there is a weight to be shouldered, and the material requires the utmost care and authenticity.” But apparently, we’re expected to accept Black Sails‘ Zach McGowan as Ben Kanahele. Hasn’t anyone learned anything from the outrage seen around the whitewashing in Ghost in the Shell, The Great Wall, Doctor Strange, Aloha, and plenty of other films?
Also, it looks like the film is shaping up to be told in a classic “John Wayne film” way. With McGowan playing the heroic leader (similar to how Wayne played POC historical heroes), it seems like the casting will go towards having a Japanese actor to play Nishikaichi, the villain. That way, they can have the white hero killing the Asian antagonist, saving the day and the native Hawaiian population (who will, of course, be played by actual native Hawaiians).
Do I need to talk at length about what’s wrong? It should be clear by now, especially if you read the articles linked above. This kind of ish has got to stop because now it’s getting ridiculous.
I’ll let Twitter speak for me because I’m tired.
This is whitewashing, plain and simple. AND IT IS COMPLETE BULLSHIT. https://t.co/KbFFMSlrTl
— Phil Yu (@angryasianman) May 10, 2017
But wait, you say. Movies need marketable stars. That's why Zach McGowan is playing a Native Hawaiian. BUT WHO THE FUCK IS ZACH MCGOWAN.
— Phil Yu (@angryasianman) May 10, 2017
Zach McGowan has been cast to play Hawaiian native Ben Kanahele in the upcoming film Ni’ihau. ARE YOU F*CKING KIDDING ME?! #Whitewashout pic.twitter.com/2ONSFCOMuH
— Laura ลอร'า 劳拉 🍥 (@lsirikul) May 9, 2017
https://twitter.com/nerdyasians/status/862171114813796355
Y'all. We were ALL wrong. @Zach_McGowan isn't playing Ben Kanahele. According to this tweet, it seems he's playing the entire island itself. https://t.co/isZ1iUIRmu
— The Nerds of Color (@TheNerdsofColor) May 15, 2017
Hey Hollywood, I know Google is hard, right? Here, found a replacement for @Zach_McGowan. It's Moses Goods, an actor already in Hawaii. pic.twitter.com/eBvQ0cTODq
— Mike Cherry (@MikeCherryKCRA) May 10, 2017
Julian 